Employees who report workplace injuries sometimes face negative consequences, including unwarranted disciplinary action, accusations of misconduct and even termination. However, Alabama law expressly prohibits employers from firing workers solely because they apply for workers’ compensation benefits. At Powell & Denny, our workers’ compensation retaliatory discharge attorneys represent injured employees throughout the state from offices located in Birmingham and Huntsville. For decades, we have used our legal acumen to help workers determine whether their termination violated state law. When it does, we help our clients understand and pursue their available remedies.
Under Alabama Code § 25-5-11.1, an employer cannot terminate an employee solely because they have sought workers’ compensation benefits. Protected conduct includes not only making an initial claim but continuing to pursue a disputed claim or an appeal. This statutory protection extends to qualifying workers’ compensation claims involving construction accidents, machinery injuries, falls and work-related car accidents. Since not every dismissal following an injury constitutes unlawful retaliation, it is important to consider an action’s timing and any surrounding circumstances.
To prevail in a retaliatory discharge claim, an employee must establish the following:
The final element presents the biggest challenge. Alabama’s statute uses the word “solely,” meaning that there must not be any other legitimate reason for the adverse employment action or termination. An experienced attorney can evaluate whether the available evidence establishes the necessary connection between your claim and your dismissal.
Employers do not openly admit to firing someone for seeking workers’ compensation benefits. As a result, circumstantial evidence can play an important role, such as:
Timing alone generally does not prove retaliation. Preserving emails, text messages, performance evaluations, disciplinary notices and termination documents can therefore be important.
An employer may defend the decision to terminate an employee by citing legitimate reasons such as the employee’s misconduct, poor work performance, attendance violations or valid workforce reductions. Importantly, Alabama law does not automatically prohibit terminating an employee who cannot perform essential job duties because of permanent medical restrictions. The circumstances surrounding the decision remain critical.
If an employer offers a reason backed by sufficient evidence, the employee will usually need to demonstrate that the explanation is just a pretext intended to conceal the retaliation. For example, an employer might suddenly enforce an attendance policy against an injured employee while overlooking comparable violations by others. Evidence of inconsistent treatment can undermine the stated reason.
A worker who successfully establishes retaliatory discharge may recover damages associated with their unlawful termination. Depending on the evidence, damages may include:
The court may limit a worker’s recoverable wage losses when an employee’s medical condition prevents further employment. A worker who cannot return to any job may be due greater damages than someone who can work but was unlawfully denied employment.
A retaliatory discharge claim is separate from the underlying workers’ compensation case. Recovering benefits for a workplace injury does not automatically establish a wrongful termination claim.
If you were fired after seeking workers’ compensation benefits, Powell & Denny can examine your employment records, termination circumstances and potential legal remedies. Based in Birmingham and Huntsville, our attorneys represent injured workers throughout Alabama. Call 800-227-0882 or contact us online to schedule a free consultation to discuss whether you may have a retaliatory discharge claim.